Wisdom Magazine's Monthly Webzine Skip Navigation Links
Wisdom Magazine is also one of the country's largest free holistic publications with 150,000 copies printed bi-monthly in three regional print editions. Wisdom is dedicated to opening people's hearts and minds to the philosophies, products and services of the new millennium.
Home  About  This Month's Articles  Calendar of Events  Classified Listings  Holistic Resource Directory
 Educational Programs  Sacred Journeys & Retreats  Yoga Teacher Training
 Article Archives  What's New in Books, CD's & DVD's  Wisdom Marketplace
 Where to Find Wisdom Near You  Subscriptions  Web Partner Links
 Advertising Information  Contact Us
Denali Institute of Northern Traditions
Miriam Smith
Margaret Ann Lembo
Maureen St Germain
Spirit Hollow
Laura Norman Reflexology
Vibes Up
Light Healing
Sacred Journeys Retreats
Alternatives For Healing

The Other Pluto

by Armand Diaz


The brusque treatment that Pluto received from astronomers in 2006 has set astrologers searching for the symbolic significance of the outermost planet’s demotion. In the process, there has been a great deal of searching back towards the mythological roots of Pluto. While this approach is certainly valid, I think it’s equally important to trace the evolution of Pluto forward from it’s discovery - after all, we have several recent symbolic manifestations which can be explored.

As you may know, the name Pluto is shared by a Disney cartoon character, who was introduced the same year that the planet was discovered. Why exactly did Disney name a cartoon mutt after the God of the Underworld? On the surface, the process was innocent enough: the dog was named for the newly discovered planet, but I find this explanation unsatisfying. Cartoon characters generally have names like “Elmo,” not “Wotan.” Sponge Bob lives in “Bikini Bottom,” not “Hell.” A symbolic analysis of the cartoon dog reveals a deeper layer of meaning, which may help us in our understanding of our attitude towards the planet Pluto.

First of all, the association of dogs and the underworld is well known. The Hounds of Hell are well established in popular mythology (see, for example, blues legend Robert Johnson’s song “Hell Hound on My Trail”), deriving from Cerberus, the three-headed dog who guards the gates of the underworld, preventing souls from leaving. So while the cartoon Pluto is named for the god himself, his association is more properly with this canine guardian.

Pluto is Mickey Mouse’s pet dog. Now, a mouse is an odd but not uncommon figure as the protagonist in a cartoon. In the Tom and Jerry cartoons, Jerry is generally seen as the innocent and Tom as the troublemaker, and Mickey himself is clearly a good guy. This is a very peculiar situation, given our typical attitude towards rodents. Mice are seen as pests, as weak annoyances, and the term “mouse” is derisive when referring to a person, as in the adjective “mousey” or the old taunt, “are you a man or a mouse?” The larger cousin of the mouse, the rat, is viewed with extreme negativity in Western culture, where a “rat” is someone who gives up the confidence of his peers (“rats” them out). The image of the rat as self-interested in the extreme also fuels the societal-oriented condemnation, “the rat race.”

We can postulate from the above that the innocent and charming Mickey and Pluto are hiding something of their (or our) true nature. It is no accident that we often choose to anthropomorphize animals, as our nature is also part animal, with all the urges and raw instincts which we see in their unadulterated form in the animal kingdom. But cartoon makers sometimes go a step further and reverse the images, so that the tame house cat is a villain, while the household vermin becomes the hero (Tom & Jerry), the serene and graceful duck becomes a lunatic (Daffy or Donald Duck), and the fierce dog becomes a cute foil (Pluto and Goofy). In the case of Mickey and Pluto, the difficult and dark side of nature is repressed, while the bright and sunny side is emphasized. Mice are suddenly “cute” and Cerberus is at worst a difficult house pet.

Walt Disney’s own description of the naming of his canine creation seems almost impossibly ironic: "There was a malaise of humanity sweeping across the country. I decided to take Nate's advice and do something fun and creative. The planet Pluto had recently been discovered and I felt it was appropriate to name the pup in its honor." Was no one at Disney’s studio familiar with mythology?

What we really see is that the absurdity of reversing the nature of the animals has reached a climax, and so in Pluto’s name we begin to see a deterioration of the situation; information about the shadow side of the cartoon family is beginning to leak through. Note also that unlike his cartoon cousin Goofy, Pluto remains a dog, he is not anthropomorphized1, another clue that the situation of idealized cartoon characters is beginning to break down, in that the Hound of Hell is too potent an image to be fully converted to a humanized equivalent.

Under the pleasant surface, are not Mickey and Pluto trying to tell us something? In the anthropomorphized mouse, we see modern man reduced to the lower order of rodentia. While Charlie Chaplin and his cohort struggled with the industrial era in Modern Times (1936), Mickey represents a defeated end to the struggle, a passive resignation to one’s fate in the “rat race,” to being a “mouse.” He accepts his two-dimensional fate, his safe but dull existence (punctuated by the occasional trip to Disneyland, no doubt). He is in Hades, the underworld, the land of pale shades, and should he try to rally his Martial energy to attempt an escape, he would surely encounter the dark side of the hound which guards his cartoonish fate.

If this seems too much of a stretch of the imagination, consider that in the cartoon in which Pluto made his first appearance, The Chain Gang (1930), he is not Mickey’s pet at all, but a bloodhound which chases Mickey after the mouse joins a prison break2. While Mickey’s memory of this episode is obviously repressed, it must have it’s unconscious effect, and indeed, Mickey’s personality in these earlier cartoons is more the mischievous prankster than the domesticated mouse he later became3. After all, some unknown offense landed him on a prison chain gang - this isn’t the mouse we know from his silent handshakes at the Magic Kingdom! The subsequent integration of (the dog) Pluto into his life has not released the powerful instincts, but has paradoxically led to their repression, seemingly the very opposite of the function of the planet Pluto. Mickey’s world then becomes a fantasy, a simulacrum, and we can sense the tension below the surface every time we watch one of his adventures. Mickey’s world is a mouse trap, and he implies that we too are caught in it, warning us not to try to break free.

A very different cartoon character from the underworld is Popeye’s nemesis Bluto (an obvious cognate of Pluto). Bluto more overtly represents dark rage, and he shows signs of being self-aware of his own evil, hence he is represented as a human. It is interesting that he is also sometimes named Brutus, suggesting both betrayal (see “rat”) and unreasoning stupidity (brute). Thus, Popeye’s struggle with Bluto is more overt and far more healing than Mickey’s passive adventures with Pluto. Popeye will not succumb to a pleasant but emotionally dead world, he is not a mouse, and so he offers us a more optimistic image, that of the hero, one who declares, “I am what I am.” Rather than appropriating and then distorting the animal kingdom in an endless pleasant fantasy, Popeye incorporates nature into himself (in the form of spinach) and uses it to assert his own Martial energy.

While Bluto confronted us with our Plutonian side, Disney’s dog led us into a maze of denial and role-reversals, demonstrating that the symbolic energy of Pluto has always been liable to repression and suppression. This suggests that the demotion of the planet is one more step in an attempt to “Disney-fy” our culture, to encourage our denial of instinctual energies (both dark and light) in favor of a pleasant, but cardboard, reality.

 

References

1. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pluto_(Disney)

2. www.imdb.com/title/tt0020752/plotsummary

3. www.imdb.com/title/tt0020752/

Armand M. Diaz, M.A., C.A., is certified as a Consulting Astrologer by the National Council for Geocosmic Research (NCGR). His approach to consultations is to create a supportive context for self-exploration, to help clients make decisions which are in harmony with their greatest potential, offering a truly integral approach to astrology. Armand has practiced divination for more than twenty years, working with the I Ching and Tarot in addition to astrology. He has published in various astrological journals, including The Mountain Astrologer. He can be reached at 917-216-1541 or armand@integralastrology.net , or though his website at www.bluemoonastrology.info.

 

Armand Diaz

Add Comment

Article Archives  This Month's Articles  Click Here for more articles by Armand Diaz
Joshua Bloom
Empowered Light Expo
Light Healing
Miriam Smith
Kiros Book
Alternatives For Healing
Spirit Hollow
Laura Norman Reflexology
Denali Institute
Margaret Ann Lembo

Call Us Toll Free: 888-577-8091 or  |  Email Us  | About Us  | Privacy Policy  | Site Map  | © 2016 Wisdom Magazine